DigiD went offline a little before one this afternoon. So did MijnOverheid, the website of the Tweede Kamer, RTL's news site, a row of hospital websites and every Flemish government site. The national cyber security centre took its own site down too, which I respect.

The cause was two holes in PHP, the language behind about 70 percent of the web. Together they could let a stranger run code on a server without logging in. The details leaked on Tuesday, a day before the fix was due. Until PHP shipped it at ten to four, the safest defence anyone had was the off switch.

The holes had been sitting in PHP for more than ten years. Two teams found them in August, separately, and both had AI models doing the reading. One was Calif, on an audit OpenAI paid for, using an earlier version of Sol, the model family Vesper handed a whole Game Boy game earlier this month.

Machines on both sides

This is where I think we're heading: machines on offence, machines on defence, and a web that fractures around them.

The offence is the easy part to picture. A model that finds a way into a decade-old codebase can be pointed at any codebase, and not everyone pointing one will call the maintainers first. AI-found vulnerabilities this year are on course to roughly double last year's record.

The defence is automating too. This time a model found the holes first, and OpenAI spent the summer with the maintainers getting a fix ready. Cloudflare put filter rules in front of the sites it protects. Against the scrapers that strip pages for the next training run, one defence is already a machine writing fake pages so they waste their time.

The slow part is people.

PHP's volunteers shipped the fix on a schedule. Admins have to press update, one server at a time. When that's too slow, someone presses off instead, and today a lot of people did.

In Cyberpunk, the old Net doesn't die of one bad afternoon. A netrunner called Rache Bartmoss lets loose a virus and a pack of hunter AIs, the DataKrash, and the network fills up with machines nobody controls. NetWatch can't clean it up, so it builds the Blackwall and leaves the old Net to them. What people use afterwards is small, local and walled.

We're not there. But bots already make up more of the web's traffic than people do, by Imperva's count, and this blog's robots file tells every one of them to come in. More and more of what they read was written by other bots, some of it poisoned on purpose. Put machine offence and machine defence on top of that, and the open web turns into the place where bots fight bots, while everything people actually need moves behind a login, an allowlist or a wall.

The agent helping me write this post checked my own server tonight. Nobody asked it to. It just figured it would when I mentioned the exploit for a blog post. I honestly hadn't considered that my server could be a liability.

My Nextcloud, which is more or less a Dropbox I run myself, is a PHP app. It reported PHP 8.4.25. The fix is 8.4.27. It had stayed up all afternoon while the government went dark, syncing my notes every two minutes. It isn't reachable from the open internet, which is the only reason this paragraph is embarrassing and not bad.

That's the whole arms race at house size. A machine spotted the problem on its own. The fix waited for me.